Federalism in Pakistan: Analyzing Sixty-Seven Years of Democratic Efforts
Keywords:
Federalism, Pakistan, Constitutions, historical perspectiveAbstract
This study seeks to investigate “Federalism” and its historical perspective
in Pakistan. Federalism refers “to a form of government where power is
distributed between the center and provinces federating units”. The paper
further traces the trajectory of three constitutions of Pakistan, 1956, 1962
and 1973 to explore federalism and changes in its structure in each
constitution. Besides, this study highlights two modes of federalism which
are dual federalism and cooperative federalism which has put the basis of
this government into practice. The findings of the study indicate that The
Government Act 1935 provided enormous powers to Governor-General,
1956 constitution provided powers to president like imposing emergency in
country and dissolution of assemblies which challenged the spirit of
federation in the country. The 1962 constitution changed the very nature of
the federal structure. The suspension of Constitution in 1977 & 1999
brought the military domination and shifting of powers to Centre which
again violated the spirit of federalism and provincial autonomy. In post
18th amendment, the Centre still violates the federal structure and ignores
the spirit of federalism in the country. The non-implementation of Article 158 and 161 (2) are the vivid example of Centre dominating and violating
the spirit of federation and constitution.
References
Abbasi, Faisal. Federalism, Provincial Autonomy, and Conflicts, 1st ed.
Islamabad: Centre for Peace and Development Initiatives, 2010.
Adeney, Katharine. The Limitations of Non- consociational Federalism:
The Example of Pakistan (2009), Ethnopolitics, 8:1, 87-106
Anwar Shah, “The 18th Constitutional Amendment: Glue or Solvent for
Nation Building and Citizenship in Pakistan?” The Lahore Journal
of Economics 17: SE (September 2012): pp. 387424
Iftikhar Ahmed and others, “National Finance Commission Awards in
Pakistan: A Historical Perspective” Islamabad, PIDE, 2007
Khalid Iram. “Politics of Federalism in Pakistan: Problems and Prospects”
South Asian Studies 28 (2013)
Katharine Adeney, “A Step Towards Inclusive Federalism in Pakistan? The
Politics of the 18th Amendment” Oxford University Press, Publius,
Vol. 42, No. 4 (Fall 2012), pp. 539-565
Khan, Zafarullah. Future of Pakistani Federation: Case Study of the Council
of Common Interests (CCI), Centre for Civic Education Pakistan,
Muntzra Nazir, “The Problems and Issues of Federalism in Pakistan”
Pakistan Vision 9: 109-128
Mansoor Akber Kundi, “Federalism in Pakistan: Issues and
Adjustment” Asian Affairs, p.23-36
Manzoor Ahmed and others, “The Experiment of Federalism
in Pakistan: An Analytical Study” Pakistan Journal of
History and Culture, Vol. XXXVII, No. 1 (2016),
p.59-72.
Tahir Mahmood, “A Comparative Analysis of the Functioning of the Senate
in USA and Pakistan” South Asian Studies Vol. 30, No.2, July –
December 2015, pp. 265 – 280
Waseem, Mohammad. Federalism in Pakistan, 1st ed. LUMS,
Zahid Mehmood, Ahmad. Institutional Analysis of Council of Common
Interests (CCI): A Guide for Functionaries, 1st ed. Islamabad:
Strengthening Participatory Federalism and Decentralization,
December 2013